Menu of The Boarding House Supper Club in Suring, Wisconsin, USA

Menu Overview

The Boarding House Supper Club, nestled in the heart of Suring, Wisconsin, offers a truly authentic steakhouse experience that marries tradition with warm hospitality. From the moment you step inside this charming, old boarding house turned supper club, you are welcomed by a cozy atmosphere where mismatched chairs and rustic decor invite you to relax and savor every bite.

The menu is a carefully curated celebration of classic supper club fare with standout dishes that leave a lasting impression. The salad bar is fresh and vibrant, featuring crisp greens and in-house made dressings that give each bite a burst of flavor—perfect as a light start or a satisfying side. The homemade hot bread served alongside warm bowls of cream of vegetable soup or beef barley soup adds a comforting, homey touch that perfectly primes the palate.

When it comes to the mains, The Boarding House excels with its steak and seafood options. The filet paired with crispy French fries is a tender cut cooked to perfection, maintaining juiciness and depth in every bite. Equally impressive is the shrimp scampi—a dish highlighted by plump, flavorful shrimp bathed in a garlic and butter sauce that balances richness with subtle acidity. The steak and shrimp combo provides the best of both worlds, delivering hearty and delicate textures in tandem. Fans of fried sides will appreciate the golden, crispy onion rings that add a satisfying crunch to the meal.

What truly distinguishes The Boarding House Supper Club is not just the food but the genuine warmth exuded by the staff. As echoed by regulars, the team knows their customers by name and approaches every guest with attentive care, turning dining into a personal and memorable event. The owner’s commitment to quality is evident—from the handcrafted cocktails like honey- and maple syrup-infused old fashioneds to the prime rib and fresh fish dishes that demonstrate a respect for fresh, local ingredients.

Overall, The Boarding House Supper Club’s menu embodies the spirit of classic American supper clubs with a focus on hearty, well-executed dishes and heartfelt hospitality. Whether you’re indulging in a filet and shrimp scampi, enjoying a bowl of soup with house bread, or unwinding at the bar with a craft bourbon cocktail, this supper club promises a dining experience that feels both timeless and personal. For anyone seeking a genuine, flavor-packed meal with a side of Midwest charm, this is a must-visit spot that earns a solid 10/10.